My phone has a 15-minute screen time limit on social media. It makes no sense, but every 15 minutes, I press the button that gives me another 15 minutes. I don't remember deciding to spend an hour and a half scrolling, but somehow, that's exactly what happens.
Just a quick glance, I tell myself. And suddenly an hour is gone. How does my 15-minute screen-time limit keep bending under this innocent-looking force?
Why technology feels so addictive
I work in marketing and often get asked what is the ideal video length for my customers social media ads, to which I always answer: “it just needs to be building up emotion right in the beginning”. Probably not exactly the answer one hoped for.
It seems that “good” content builds up emotion fast, and these emotions gets us hooked – hello engagement. Algorithms, especially on social media and short form videos, have maybe realized that we are all suckers for “what will happen next, what will happen next, what will happen…”. Even secondhand marketplace Vinted, seems to be joining the party.
We want to know where the story goes, if the guy in the suit is really going to make over that ditch with the half broken stick. Of course not, but we need to see it. Something surprising might happen.
Infinite scroll, the notifications, the red dot’s on app icons on the homescreen. Have you seen your Facebook notification center lately, its insane! Number of likes, the personalized recommendation feed. The Vinted feed with endless bargain possibilities. It all exploits the same question in our heads.
Brains: “What will happen next?”
One of my favorite ideas from neuroscience is that our brains don't simply experience the present. They are constantly trying to predict what happens next, and whether we should do something about it. And those predictions can create a powerful feeling: anticipation.
Big chunks of our lives are lived in these kind of simulations – sometimes run consciously, often sub-consciously. Its so hard to stay in the present that we need to meditate, run, cold plunge, etc, just to calm our prediction machines down and return to the ground.
Perhaps the most interesting part is that wanting and liking aren't actually the same thing. Neuroscientists have been studying this distinction for decades. We can be strongly motivated to get something without particularly enjoying it when we do. And I wonder if that's what makes the modern internet so strange.
We're not necessarily scrolling because we're having a great time. We're scrolling because the next thing might be great. The next video, the next notification, the next bargain, the next idea.
We've built an internet that's exceptionally good at making us want what's next. But perhaps not quite as good at making us appreciate what we've already found. The internet has made the creation of curiosity almost frictionless, while making the decision to stop increasingly difficult.
Maybe this is currently wrong with our internet. It’s designed around anticipation rather than satisfaction. Wanting but not liking. Like a loop that never gets closed. Like a slot machine, where the next pull could bring the jackpot, but never does.
What are we really selling and buying?
If this idea is somewhere close to truth, then social media isn’t really selling content, but the possibility that the next piece of information will be interesting for us.
Even news can become less about understanding what's happening and more about checking whether something important has happened since I last looked. And investing? It can be driven just as much by imagined future returns as by what's actually happening today. TikTok algorithm endlessly measuring and estimating what would keep us hooked as long as possible. Anticimaxxing?
And here's where this gets slightly uncomfortable for me. Because I work in advertising. And a big part of my job is figuring out how to create exactly the kind of anticipation I've just spent at least ten paragraphs reflecting on.
So what should the next ad creative look like? Whatever it is, it will be competing with content designed to be as engaging as humanly possible. The ChatGPT generated webinar post with the rocket emoji doesn’t do really well in this context.
Maybe you need to understand who you are talking to and actually talk to them. Like a real conversation, with a customer, not just a random person sitting on a metro bench blasted with some marketing content.
The trouble with wanting more
The ability to be emotionally attached to an imagined future is arguably one of humanity’s greatest strengths, but it’s also one of our greatest vulnerabilities. This is probably why my 15-minute timer bends.
The same mechanism that helps us build businesses, cities and inventions can keep us using technologies for hours. The same force that drives innovation drives our digital addiction.
And just look at the title of this post. A little anticipation, a question you wanted answered.
What if the most valuable thing the internet has learned to produce isn't really content, but the feeling that something better is always one scroll away?
P.S. I really enjoyed this video from Big Think around this topic
